Within the ever-expanding world of quick-fix well being dietary supplements, it’s straightforward to search out wild claims and doubtful analysis. Though even the best greens powders aren’t a substitute for good old style fruits and veggies, their spectacular vitamin and mineral counts, antioxidants, and adaptogenics might earn a spot in your food regimen. Our consultants warning that the analysis on these dietary supplements is in its infancy, however some research point out they may doubtlessly assist decrease blood stress, enhance coronary heart well being, and enhance the immune system. (1)(2)(3)(4)
Two of probably the most recognizable powders available on the market (thanks, social media algorithms) are doubtless acquainted names — Jocko Greens and AG1 (aka Athletic Greens). Whereas it might seem to be these widespread greens powders are the magic potion for avoiding precise veggies, what precisely have they got to supply? After testing out practically 40 greens powders, we all know what separates the too-good-to-be-true’s from the best-for-you’s. Take a look at what our crew of registered dietitian nutritionists, licensed vitamin coaches, and total well being nuts need to say in our head-to-head showdown of Jocko Greens vs. Athletic Greens.
What’s Jocko Greens?
Jocko Greens is the greens powder providing from Jocko Gas, the well being and efficiency complement firm based by retired U.S. Navy Seal Jocko Willink. Greens powder dietary supplements like Jocko Greens are designed to assist complement essential micronutrients that many people wrestle to include into our diets. However with so many nutritional vitamins and minerals (and proprietary greens blends of nutritional vitamins and minerals), inspecting the ingredient record of any greens powder could be an exhausting activity.
After we had our professional reviewer and registered dietitian nutritionist Chelsea Rae Bourgeois scrutinize the label, she factors out that, in contrast to some others on this crowded market, what you see is what you get. “Whereas I’m often cautious of greens powders, I admire that Jocko is clear with their ingredient blends,” she says. “They embody the quantity of every ingredient of their blends, giving prospects a transparent image of what they’re shopping for. I additionally admire that it’s free from added sugars.”
One key inclusion in its system is the handful of adaptogens — ashwagandha, milk thistle, and rhodiola — that caught the attention of licensed vitamin coach Jesse Zucker once they checked it out for themself. “These are marketed to extend your power, and ashwagandha is usually taken to advertise leisure,” they are saying. “Adaptogens are primarily substances that assist your physique return to homeostasis from what you’re missing — so should you’re drained, they may provide help to really feel extra alert. If stress ranges are too excessive, they could assist carry them down.” (5)
Many greens powders solely are available in an unflavored — however actually, grass-flavored — possibility, however Jocko Greens gives Pineapple Coconut and Peach. Not solely can these tasty flavors make it a bit extra palatable, however they use the pure sweeteners cane sugar and monk fruit extract. “I do know it’s not everybody’s favourite, however for me, the Peach taste is fairly good,” says licensed vitamin coach and BarBend editorial crew member Alex Polish. “I feel I’m delicate to synthetic sweeteners (they’re often approach too robust for me), so this one tastes loads milder than most greens powders for me.”
Learn our full Jocko Greens Review.
What’s Athletic Greens?
After I stated that greens powders labels could be a prolonged learn, I used to be considering of social media and wellness podcast darling AG1. With over 75 entire food-sourced components, this do-it-all complement can help a variety of constructive well being outcomes, like improved intestine well being, hormone perform, immunity, liver perform, elevated power, and extra.
“AG1’s lineup has so many high quality components — nutritional vitamins, probiotics, minerals, adaptogens — I can’t actually see a draw back to utilizing it,” says one member of our crew, a licensed private coach. In truth, the mix of components goals to function the entire following:
- Multivitamin
- Multimineral
- Stress adaptogens
- Prebiotics
- Probiotics
- Antioxidants
- Superfoods
- Useful mushrooms
- Digestive enzymes
Simply as spectacular could also be what it lacks — synthetic flavors, sweeteners, colours, preservatives, and GMOs. AG1 has additionally been examined by impartial labs for impurities like heavy metals, pathogens, mould, and yeasts. Plus, aggressive athletes can breathe simpler figuring out it’s NSF Licensed for Sport, so it is freed from banned substances.
“The flavour is a bit delicate, however it’s simply the best-tasting greens powder I’ve had,” says one other of our testers. Quite than compromise its formulation with synthetic sweeteners like sucralose or aspartame, every serving of AG1 comprises lower than one gram of sugar derived from stevia leaves. “It’s robust to make these powders style like something, so utilizing pure sources of pineapple and vanilla is actually going the additional mile,” they add.
For our professional reviewer, Chelsea Rae Bourgeois, RDN, AG1’s system makes it a standout in a crowded market, however she notes that it comes at a steep price. “AG1 Athletic Greens present a concentrated supply of vitamins, together with helpful probiotics,” she says. “[It] will get a 3 out of 5 for its formulation, with main deductions for its proprietary blends and price. For a lot of, the associated fee doesn’t match the purported advantages.”
Learn our full Athletic Greens AG1 Review.
Jocko Greens vs. Athletic Greens At a Look
For a have a look at the chilly, laborious details, take a look at the important thing stats for each of those greens powder dietary supplements.
| Jocko Greens | Athletic Greens | |
| Worth | $49.99 | $99 |
| Worth Per Serving | $1.66 | $3.30 |
| Servings Per Container | 30 | 30 |
| Third-Celebration Testing | Sure | Sure |
| Standout Elements | Natural vegetable mix, natural fruit mix, rhodiola extract, ashwagandha extract, milk thistle extract, 9 billion CFUs probiotics mix (11 strains) | Superfood advanced, herb & antioxidant mix, digestive enzymes, mushroom mix, probiotics (7.2 billion CFU from 2 strains) |
| Diet Per Scoop | 30 energy, 0.5g fats, 6g carbs, 2g protein, 1g fiber, 2g sugar, 50mg calcium, 3mg iron, 40mg sodium, 140mg potassium | 50 energy, 6g carbs, 2g fiber, <1g sugar, 2g protein, fat not disclosed |
| Sweeteners Used | Fermented cane sugar, monk fruit extract | Stevia |
| Accessible Flavors | Pineapple Coconut, Peach | Unflavored |
Jocko Greens vs. Athletic Greens: The Nitty Gritty
As two of the extra widespread greens dietary supplements on the market, Jocko Greens and Athletic Greens each have loads of well being advantages to supply. To get a greater sense of which is likely to be the perfect match for whom, I’ve tapped registered dietitian nutritionist Chelsea Rae Bourgeois and authorized vitamin coach Jesse Zucker to dive just a little deeper.
Pricing
Most greens powders will run you about $1 to $1.50 per serving. For a bit extra context, two others that we like, Clear Labs Prebiotic Greens and Nested Naturals Super Greens, price $1.53 and $1.07 per serving, respectively. So proper off the bat, each Jocko Greens and AG1 exceed the typical value of a greens powder.
Whereas each supply a slight low cost with a subscription, when stacked up head-to-head, it’s not even shut. At $1.66 per serving ($1.50 should you subscribe), Jocko Greens simply eclipses the standard vary we see amongst greens powders. However, as Bourgeois highlights, AG1’s $3.30 per serving ($2.63 with a subscription) pulverizes that common vary like a finely-grained, nicely, greens powder.
“The fee is the largest turn-off for me with this product,” she says. “AG1 Athletic Greens might assist enhance your consumption of essential vitamins, nevertheless it undoubtedly comes at a price — and the associated fee ain’t low cost! On a funds, I’d be extra inclined so as to add extra nutrient-dense entire meals to my food regimen to acquire the identical results.”
A 30-serving container of Jocko Greens rings up at $49.99, simply half the worth of the equal AG1 pouch. That $100 month-to-month expense is likely to be the top of the dialogue for many, though you possibly can cut back the price of a single container to $79 ($2.63 per serving) by signing up for a subscription. That 20% value reduce bests the ten% you save when subscribing to Jocko Greens ($1.50 per serving), however the backside line is that Jocko Greens is far more inexpensive.
The winner: Jocko Greens
Third-Celebration Testing
As a result of the FDA doesn’t approve well being or efficiency dietary supplements earlier than they hit the market, seeing some kind of impartial verification of the system is significant. The best pre-workout supplements, protein powders, and creatine are sometimes examined for banned substances to offer aggressive athletes peace of thoughts, as nicely.
A possible wrongdoer of AG1’s excessive value is the quantity of testing that batch goes by. It’s examined for practically 1,000 impurities, like heavy metals, pesticides, and herbicides. Though, it isn’t clear whether or not this testing is completed independently or by AG1. It’s, nonetheless, stamped with the NSF Licensed for Sport seal of approval, which suggests it’s freed from practically 300 substances which are banned in sports activities.
Whereas NSF certification is nothing to sneeze at, AG1 contains a number of proprietary blends, so we will’t know for certain precisely how a lot of every ingredient is included inside each. We’d have appreciated to see the system itself, however seeing that NSF stamp on the label is sufficient for our testers to attain its third-party testing 5 out of 5. For Bourgeois, it additionally added a little bit of reassurance. “Because the analysis behind greens powders is missing, I like that this product is third-party examined for security,” she says.
The Jocko Greens story is a bit murkier. Based on the Jocko Gas web site, Jocko Greens has been third-party examined, however as Zucker notes, there isn’t any info on which lab carried out the testing or verified these statements. “They are saying their merchandise and components come from GMP-certified services and FDA-licensed producers, which is nice,” they are saying. “In addition they state {that a} third-party lab verified every of those components earlier than making their dietary supplements, [but] figuring out the lab’s identify and the report outcomes can be higher because it’s one thing different corporations do. I’ll give it a 3 out of 5 for the services utilized in manufacturing.”
The Winner: Athletic Greens
Standout Elements
For any of the best supplements for weight loss, constructing muscle, or total well being that Bourgeois and Zucker study, the inclusion of proprietary blends is an enormous deal. Enterprise-wise, we get it. Publishing actual quantities of every ingredient would make it simpler for one more firm to duplicate. However for the buyer (the particular person actually consuming it), proprietary blends make it unattainable to know precisely how a lot of every ingredient is current. On this case, it’s fairly easy. AG1 has them and Jocko Greens doesn’t.
What we will see, nonetheless, is fairly spectacular in each of those powders. Each comprise blends loaded with entire meals components, like natural spirulina, wheatgrass, and chlorella. “Spirulina (blue-green algae) is a inexperienced superfood that has robust antioxidant properties,” Zucker says. “Wheatgrass is a grass that additionally has antioxidant and anti inflammatory properties. Chlorella is one other kind of antioxidant-rich algae excessive in iron.” (6)(7)(8)
One other spotlight for each is the inclusion of adaptogens, like ashwagandha, milk thistle, and rhodiola. Whereas extra analysis is required on these components, they’re thought to spice up power ranges and focus. (5) Each additionally embody digestion-supporting probiotics. “Jocko Greens has 9 billion CFUs of probiotics, which assist stability intestine micro organism and might enhance digestive well being,” Zucker notes. ‘They’re a very good addition to this product, the place you’re ingesting many uncooked components without delay.” (9)
AG1’s 7.2 billion CFUs from two strains — Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifidobacterium bifidum — might equally improve gut health and help digestion. It additionally contains prebiotics and digestive enzymes, whereas Jocko Greens solely comprises probiotics. (10)(11)
The winner: It’s a tie.
Diet Per Scoop
With so many components in these greens powders, it may be straightforward to get overwhelmed. First, let’s begin together with your macronutrients. Right here’s a fast per-serving breakdown to assist make counting macros easier.
Jocko Greens:
- 30 energy
- 6g carbs (1g fiber, 2g sugar)
- 0.5g fats
- 2g protein
AG1:
- 50 energy
- 6g carbs (2g fiber, <1g sugar)
- Fats content material not disclosed
- 2g protein
Past these key figures, Bourgeois likes what she sees from AG1, scoring its formulation 3 out of 5. However after factoring in its eye-popping value per serving, she has some reservations. “Sadly, AG1 Athletic Greens is full of proprietary blends, so that you don’t actually even know what you’re spending your cash on,” she notes.
Now, whereas the quantities of the components in its 4 blends — Alkaline, Nutrient-Dense, Uncooked Superfood Complicated; Nutrient-Dense Pure Extracts, Herbs, & Antioxidants; Digestive Enzyme & Tremendous Mushroom Complicated; Dairy-Free Probiotics — are obscured, the precise quantities of 26 nutritional vitamins, minerals, and macronutrients are listed on the label.
By itself, AG1 may nicely be one of many best multivitamin supplements available on the market. In every serving, you’re getting over 100% of your each day really useful worth of vitamin A, vitamin C, vitamin E, and a few B nutritional vitamins. The mineral content material additionally contains strong dosages of calcium, magnesium, sodium, and potassium.
So, what in regards to the vitamin content material for Jocko Greens? That’s precisely what Bourgeois was questioning, too. “Jocko Greens Powder appears fairly commonplace relating to greens powders,” she says. “It features a few spectacular components in small quantities, however the vitamin details are just a little underwhelming. Aside from its macronutrients, Jocko Greens Powder solely supplies the vitamin details for potassium, sodium, iron, and calcium supplied within the product.”
“Every serving supplies 18% of the each day worth for iron and simply 2 to 4% for the remaining vitamins,” she provides, score its system 2.5 out of 5. “Whereas the blends in Jocko Greens Powder might embody small quantities of meals that you simply won’t usually eat, the vitamin details don’t point out they’re considerably contributing to your each day nutrient wants. There are numerous different cheaper and gratifying methods to get these vitamins (and in larger quantities) by entire meals.”
The winner: Athletic Greens
Sweeteners Used
Greens powders aren’t usually thought to be tasty additions to your food regimen and most solely come within the ever-appealing “unflavored” selection. That is the case for AG1, though it does use stevia and the, in keeping with the corporate, “pure essence of pineapple core and vanilla bean.”
Associated: Is Stevia the Most Gut-Healthy Sweetener?
Stevia has been recognized to go away a robust aftertaste and even trigger digestive points for some folks. Jocko Greens, then again, makes use of fermented cane sugar and the pure sweetener monk fruit extract to attain its two flavors — Pineapple Coconut and Peach.
The winner: It’s a tie.
Accessible Flavors
Whereas technically AG1 will not be flavored, one in every of our testers undoubtedly picked up on the tropical really feel the model is aiming for. “It doesn’t trouble me that there aren’t taste choices for Athletic Greens as a result of the grassiness is fairly gentle,” they are saying. “However I’ll say, I detect notes of pineapple and vanilla.”
We haven’t had the possibility to check out the Pineapple Coconut selection from Jocko Greens, however the Peach was a little bit of a lightning rod for 2 members of our crew. “I really feel so unhealthy saying this, however the Peach taste is simply not one thing I can drink during,” one says. “It’s simply too overpowering.” Nevertheless, licensed private coach and vitamin coach Alex Polish feels in a different way. “I do get the Peach taste, which can be uncommon (for me, most powders style generically candy moderately than like no matter they’re promoting),” they are saying. “So, a powerful 4 out of 5 for me.”
The Winner: Jocko Greens
Style
First off, greens powders don’t supply the wide-ranging flavors of the best protein powders or creatine dietary supplements. Whereas it’d technically be “unflavored,” AG1 earns a 4.5 out of 5 for style from two members of our crew — each licensed private trainers. “With so many unsweetened, unadorned greens powders on the market that style like literal filth, I like AG1’s pineapple and vanilla notes that border on tropical,” says BarBend tester Nick English. “Nevertheless, I nonetheless get a bit an excessive amount of of an earthy and grassy style.”
“AG1 actually has a ‘wholesome’ style, nevertheless it’s superior to even different flavored powders,” one other tester says. “You continue to must mood expectations, however there’s a good quantity of sweetness to it due to the stevia and pure pineapple and vanilla flavoring.”
The Peach taste of Jocko Greens earnesa 4 out of 5 from Polish, however one other of our testers will not be so impressed. “I hate losing meals — or dietary supplements, because it have been — however I all the time need to dump this out midway by consuming it,” they are saying, scoring this feature simply 2 out of 5. “You’ll be able to inform that they’re attempting to masks the earthy, leafy flavors — nevertheless it’s approach an excessive amount of overcompensation for me.”
The Winner: Athletic Greens
Solubility
In life and in greens powders, setting expectations is essential. Even the best shaker bottles can wrestle to fully combine a greens powder, so the truth that each Jocko Greens and AG1 earned scores of 4 out of 5 from our crew was noteworthy. We simply counsel giving it a shake earlier than every sip.
“The great factor right here is that it mixes proper up with a shaker, and even by stirring it in a glass,” one tester says of Jocko Greens. “It does settle a bit on the backside should you go away it out, however a fast shake or stir earlier than every drink ought to care for that simply.”
“This mixes like many different greens powders I’ve tried — fairly nicely. I exploit a shaker cup and it simply takes just a few robust shakes,” Polish provides. “In the event you’re taking your time consuming it and letting it sit as an alternative of simply downing it, I’d suggest giving it an additional shake earlier than every sip”
Our crew relayed the same story for AG1. “It’ll settle should you let it sit for some time, however typically, I drink mine in a single sitting so it’s not a problem,” our tester notes. “Be ready for just a bit grit, however you received’t get any clumps with a shaker bottle, and it goes down good and simple.”
The Winner: It’s a tie.
Results
Even after hands-on testing or prolonged use, it may be tough to pinpoint the acute results of dietary supplements like greens superfood powders. With such sturdy lineups for nutritional vitamins and minerals, it’s straightforward to be ok with beefing up the micronutrient depend with a each day greens powder scoop. However as Bourgeois explains, she wish to see a bit extra scientific proof relating to their efficacy.
Associated: Micronutrients for Athletes
“There’s a number of thriller surrounding the hype of greens powders,” she says. “You is likely to be stunned to search out {that a} greens powder solely provides extra to an already met want. A dietitian can assist you resolve if a greens powder is important.”
After attempting each Jocko Greens and AG1, our crew hasn’t seen any rapid uncomfortable side effects. The one be aware that one tester relayed about Jocko Greens is almost certainly relevant throughout many greens powders. “I wouldn’t advise taking this on an empty abdomen,” they be aware. “It’s not unhealthy, however I’ve had a little bit of bloating or a abdomen ache after I had this and nothing else in my system.”
One member of our crew who tried Athletic Greens appreciated the constructive impact of including nutritional vitamins and minerals to their food regimen on their psychological well-being. “Nothing felt overly adverse and nothing felt overly constructive,” they are saying. “That’s commonplace for this sort of dietary complement, nevertheless it did give me a number of consolation to know that I’m getting extra micronutrients than I in any other case may!”
“There’s no actual draw back right here as a result of it’s full of all the fitting stuff — besides the worth,” one other tester provides. “However should you can afford it, it’s a 5 out of 5 from me.”
The Winner: It’s a tie.
Jocko Greens vs. Athletic Greens FAQ
Is Jocko Greens the identical as AG1?
Each are gluten-free and share some similarities of their micronutrient content material. AG1 contains 4 proprietary blends whereas Jocko Greens comprises none. AG1 does embody prebiotics and digestive enzymes, however its value per serving is roughly double Jocko Greens. However anybody on the lookout for a non-GMO greens powder ought to go together with AG1.
What greens are higher than Athletic Greens?
AG1 is our high total decide among the many practically 40 plant-based greens powders that now we have personally examined. Others that fee extremely are Clear Labs Prebiotic Greens and Ora Natural Greens.
Is Jocko Greens third-party examined for contaminants?
Jocko Gas states that Jocko Greens has been third-party examined, however there are not any particulars about which lab or group carried out the testing.
Do greens powders work?
References
- Kechagia, M., Basoulis, D., Konstantopoulou, S., Dimitriadi, D., Gyftopoulou, Okay., Skarmoutsou, N., & Fakiri, E. M. (2013). Well being advantages of probiotics: a evaluate. ISRN vitamin, 2013, 481651.
- Zhang, J., Bateman, R., Metzger, S., & Lanigan, Okay. (2006). Taking dietary dietary supplements for 3 months lowered blood stress however not blood lipid ranges in college students. Journal of chiropractic drugs, 5(2), 53–59.
- Zhang, J., Oxinos, G., & Maher, J. H. (2009). The impact of fruit and vegetable powder combine on hypertensive topics: a pilot research. Journal of chiropractic drugs, 8(3), 101–106.
- Lorenzoni, G., Minto, C., Vecchio, M. G., Zec, S., Paolin, I., Lamprecht, M., Mestroni, L., & Gregori, D. (2019). Fruit and Vegetable Focus Supplementation and Cardiovascular Well being: A Systematic Assessment from a Public Well being Perspective. Journal of scientific drugs, 8(11), 1914.
- Todorova, V., Ivanov, Okay., Delattre, C., Nalbantova, V., Karcheva-Bahchevanska, D., & Ivanova, S. (2021). Plant Adaptogens-Historical past and Future Views. Vitamins, 13(8), 2861.
- Ku, C. S., Yang, Y., Park, Y., & Lee, J. (2013). Well being advantages of blue-green algae: prevention of heart problems and nonalcoholic fatty liver illness. Journal of medicinal meals, 16(2), 103–111.
- Gunjal, M., Kaur, J., Rasane, P., Singh, J., Kaur, S., Bakshi, M., Choudhary, R., Alina Marc, R., & Ercisli, S. (2024). Dietary Significance of Wheatgrass: Cultivation Practices and Alternatives for its Processing and Preservation. Latest advances in meals, vitamin & agriculture, 10.2174/012772574X275920231214053122. Advance on-line publication.
- Bito, T., Okumura, E., Fujishima, M., & Watanabe, F. (2020). Potential of Chlorella as a Dietary Complement to Promote Human Well being. Vitamins, 12(9), 2524.
- Williams N. T. (2010). Probiotics. American journal of health-system pharmacy : AJHP : official journal of the American Society of Well being-System Pharmacists, 67(6), 449–458.
- Quigley E. M. M. (2019). Prebiotics and Probiotics in Digestive Well being. Medical gastroenterology and hepatology : the official scientific follow journal of the American Gastroenterological Affiliation, 17(2), 333–344.
- Janciauskiene S. (2020). The Useful Results of Antioxidants in Well being And Ailments. Power obstructive pulmonary illnesses (Miami, Fla.), 7(3), 182–202.